Proposed FWC change for Holeylands/ Atv's for hunting only

[lswjth2]

Folks, here's the link for the FWC proposed rule change for holeylands. Atv's will only be allowed during hunting season. Scroll down to about 2/3 of the page and look for holeylands, click on this and you can voice your comments....


http://myfwc.com/commission/RuleChanges/ProposedRules0708.asp

[Young Gun]

"Holeylands – establish a 105-day small game season and allow the use of ATVs for hunting purposes only and only during archery, muzzleloading gun and general gun-walk seasons and for scouting purposes one week prior to the start of each season."

[digginfool]

Folks, this is our only opportunity to save this riding area.  Once they close the area, it will be nearly impossible to get it back.  PLEASE take five minutes to write a well-thought out, RESPECTFUL response to the rule change proposals.  Just click on the green button and it will take you to the submission form.  Talk about the majority of us who use and respect the land, acknowledge there are issues that need to be resolved, offer your help to find solutions to those issues.  SHOW THAT YOU CARE!!  THIS IS OUR ONLY CHANCE!!!

This is my response:

"I am extremely disappointed with the proposed rule restricting the use of ATVs.  The State of Florida promised an increase in riding areas with the implementation of titling and registration fees.  Instead, we have seen a continual reduction in the allowable areas to operate ATVs.  The Holeylands/Rotenberger/Everglades and Francis S Taylor WMAs are one of the only areas available in South Florida to operate ATVs.  I beg you not to pass this rule change.  I know there are issues that need to be resolved but please do not take this away from the vast majority of us riders that are responsible and respectful of these lands.  Every year, my children, my wife and I travel far and wide across the Holeylands, Everglades and Francis S Taylor WMAs inparticular, which gives us an experience that few Floridians ever experience.  It's also an experience we would not be able to enjoy without the access an ATV gives us to these wilderness areas.  Certainly, there are other means of dealing with the issues that clearly exist out there than an outright ban.  Please reconsider.  I would happily become involved with any committee or sit on any panel to address this issue and develop feasible alternatives to this proposal."

[AintSkeered]

Submitted my comments! If you don't have the time or literary skills to submit your own response, just cut/paste digginfool's and edit to your liking. Please. Are there enough of us willing to go get hunting licenses and noisily "bag our limits" every weekend during hunting season? How about buggies? Can we all go buy those and ride them out there?

[TRX450R_Racer]

Done

[brett711]

done..

[lswjth2]

Here's what I sent in via e-mail to the FWC people I know. There's only a 1500 character limit.

I want to take this opportunity to voice our opposition to the proposed rule change not only in this WMA, but ALL WMA where you are looking to close ATV/OHV and recreational activities. ATV/OHV use is a "cultural and Historic" part of Florida. Unfortunately, I, my children, and the rest of the future generations are becoming "Cultural refugees" in our backyard. Public lands are for the public to use, and while I will not deny that there have been and continue to be abuses, this is a very small minority when compared to the larger population that enjoy this kind of family activity. The state of Florida has the third highest sales of atv's  in the nation, however with the constant appointments of people like Dr. Reed Noss to the state ARC committee and recently the appointment of Estinoz by SFWMD our future looks even bleaker for our children.

In 2002 the state legislature passed the Mark T. Schmidt Recreation act where the state collects an additional $ 35.00 in registration fees to buy land for OHV recreation. In this same act it clearly states that lands purchased under the "Florida Forever act" may be used for OHV recreation as long as certain criteria is met (Florida owns over 5 MILLION ACRES OF PUBLIC LAND). Why does it take a "Study" to open up an area but not to close it? Where are these reports where you can justify such actions? I will tell you that the "everglades restoration" is a total farce and under this guise, SFWMD has illegally shut down the Picayune forest. CERP is under WRDA and in WRDA it clearly state that "historic and cultural" uses are to be protected.

Today we spend BILLIONS OF DOLLARS ON PROTECTING DIRT, dirt that eventually will be sold to developers or become STA areas because of BIG SUGAR  and the EAA runoff into the Glades. Our Glades are turning into a massive sewage treatment plant and you are telling me that my 8-inch wide tire track hurts the environment? At least be honest with yourselves.

I had a face-to-face conversation with one of your biologist over at Cecil Webb WMA when we had proposed during a cleanup ride at this WMA. I was told to my face that we were not wanted there. This is nothing more than outright discrimination. We, the ATV community, are the "NEW BLACKS" of the south. Where no one wants us anywhere and our only crime is to spend time with our children enjoying OUR PUBLIC LANDS. Could you imagine if you said this to a person of color in any other public venue what the repercussions would be? Why is it that in Cecil Webb, it's perfectly legal to ride a licensed car or an unlicensed swamp buggy but not an ATV? The law was written to specifically exclude us and our children from PUBLIC LAND.

You need to take a long hard look at this proposed rule change and instead of closing areas to the recreational families of this state, engage the different ATV clubs around and use us a force for good. We can have cleanup rides, raise money for charities, help with search and rescue and may I suggest before you automatically put us all in the same pot (profiling) engage those of us that are responsible and value what little we have left. Thank you

[JackL]

Typing mine right now.

[LINK500]

Done...

[CliffB]

Done....

[DOITHARD]

DONE!

[AintSkeered]

ttt

[4MANFREAK]

voiced my opinion...

[mud.junkie]

Done!!!!

[EigerGuy]

Done..... TTT

[HVYHLR53]

I think that everyone is reading the "proposed" change in the laws incorrectly. Every sentence in there has something to do with the hunting season. If they were killing our riding area other then during the hunt season, there would be a sentence in there stating that ATVs are prohibited and it wouldn't be mixed in the paragraph with new proposed hunting laws.

[jrpro130]

They are just prohibiting atv's during hunting season recreationally.

For the time being, I'm just riding other spots.

[EigerGuy]

ya during hunting season they want only hunters off the levys your still allowed to go out but u have 2 wait until sundown, to make sure u dont get shot with an arrow

[Keeter]

Done

[brett711]

commision meeting is this week.

[brett711]

quote from the broward county airboat club:

Right now the FWC is in their rule making period. At the last meeting of the year they will vote on the proposed rules for the upcoming year. And to answer your question, right now they are proposing to only allow ATV use during hunting season and one week prior for scouting in Holy Lands, Rotenberg, and Area 3 north and south. As a club we are at least trying to get camp owners special use permits for using their Atv's to get to their camp in a low water situation. But from what we are seeing this rule will get passed thru for the upcoming year. You can go in the FWC website, look under commission meetings, and read the agenda and the proposed rules for clarification. I hope this answers your question.

[soflorider]

This is upsurd! Buggies and airboats still allowed and we only ride their trails! Furthermore, In December of 2007 the commission tried to pass this rule and 31 people and 11 organizations said NO. Then, all of a sudden it was voted on again in February, only 2 months later, and it magically passes! Check it out for yourself on page 28 of this link:

http://myfwc.com/commission/2007/Sept07/Documents/MajorProposedRuleChangesforWildlifeandFreshwaterFish4C2.pdfThere’s something shaddy going on here.

Here's the guy to call: Chuck Collins 561-625-5131. Please we need everyone's help!

Here's the FWC's press release:
News Release

FWC passes ATV restrictions for 3 South Fla. WMAs

February 26, 2008
Contact: Chuck Collins, 561-625-5131

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) has passed new rules regarding the use of ATVs on Everglades and Francis Taylor, Holey Land and Rotenberger wildlife management areas (WMAs). 

Effective July 1, 2008, the use of ATVs will be allowed for hunting purposes only and only during the archery, muzzleloading gun and general gun seasons.  In addition, ATVs will be allowed for scouting purposes two weeks before archery season and one week before the start of muzzleloading gun and general gun-walk seasons.

The unrestricted use of ATVs on these WMAs has resulted in extensive resource damage and public safety concerns.  The FWC took this action following its rulemaking process, which included publicizing proposed rules on its Web site in August and September 2007, publishing the proposed rules in the Florida Administrative Weekly and public meetings in September and December 2007 and February 2008.

Final consideration of this rule by FWC took place at the February Commission meeting. For further information, see the meeting agenda at MyFWC.com/Commission/2008/Feb08/index.html.   

The FWC is a member of the Florida Off-highway Vehicle Advisory Council.  The council is working with riding groups to develop safe and sustainable riding sites in Florida.  For more information on the council see www.floridaohv.org.

[Anoriginal]

Sorry dude, you're a little too late.